Skip to main content

Stream-of-Consciousness Narration

How, why, and to what effect does Mahfouz use stream-of-consciousness narration in the novel?



The stream of consciousness narrative within the technique extremely elevates the themes and characters presented as it gives to contrasting perspectives. Juxtaposing the internal thoughts of the protagonist is a calm objective third person narrative which primarily provides description of the events, surroundings and characters of the novel. This provides the readers with all the external facts and details needed to interpret the story and the actions of characters. However, its seemingly calm and monotone narrative contrasts with the internal thoughts/dialogue of Said which is in italics for ease the reading and understanding of the novel. Said's thoughts present opinion, emotion and a first person perspective which is absent from the other narrative which almost entirely characterizes Said. His bursts of thought present his internal conflicts and how they are what fuel his actions, to some extent, reasoning them to the viewer. The internal thought expresses his hubris and hamartia which develops his character as a tragic hero as well as divulging on his negative emotion like hate and his want for revenge as well as his positive ones like his love for Sana or Nur. This is constantly evident in his descriptions of the traitors within his life as they are most commonly paired with descriptions of Sana or Nur as he decided to spare Nabbawiya's life purely because of Sana. His descriptions of himself and others aid in characterization as well as foreshadowing to his tragic hero fate as he continuously describes himself as this superior thief while the third person narrator reveals all his failures. Which is highlighted in his consciousness prior his actions like breaking into Rauf's house or attempting to kill Ilish as he describes himself using animal imagery while the third person narrator describes his failure the next day. 
Information and characterization from the third person narrator and stream of consciousness narrative technique creates a three dimensional protagonist with a number of flaws and good qualities. It evokes a sense of sympathy and frustration within the audience as they want to root for Said but disagree with his actions and methods of achieving his happy ending. The third person narrative is objective giving an unbiased description of his actions and interactions which exaggerates his internal thoughts as the viewer is exposed to the multiple positive paths he could take. However, due to the corruption of his hubris and hamartia which are expressed in his consciousness, it is as if he cannot change path no matter how hard he tries. After breaking into Ruf's house, both failed attempts at murder and Nur's disappearance, Said is not discouraged or doubts his behaviour but his hamartia continuous to fuel his external conflicts due to his resistance to change and acceptance which is constantly revealed in his consciousness. 
The stream of consciousness narrative technique relates heavily to Mahfouz's context of production as he has expressed his confusion and perplexities during the events of his time through the character of Said. Said's constant struggle with his "traitors", the government and general environment mirrors Mahfouz's struggle with Nasser's changing state as certain aspects which were promised were not fulfilled. Mahfouz cultivates his frustration and opposition through the character of Said due to the censorship of that time as Nasser's rule tended to be hierarchical in adversaries and media with the censorship of both if opposition was present. This ruling power was also described between the relationship of Rauf and Said and Rauf's rebellious spirit is lost in his bureaucratic lifestyle dividing the bond between them and mirroring the separation that occurred between certain classes. This is reiterated in Nur's description of what people thought of Said as the Taxi driver believed Said highlighted justice but was mistaken in his actions while the higher clansman envisioned him as a form of entertainment for the lower class citizens.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Thief and the Dogs Passage Analysis Ch. 4

Chapter Four Passage: "You made me and now you reject me: Your ideas create their embodiment in my person and then you simply change them, leaving me lost –rootless, worthless, without hope—a betrayal so vile that if the whole Muqattam hill toppled over and buried it, I still would not be satisfied. I wonder if you ever admit, even to yourself, that you betrayed me. Maybe you’ve deceived yourself as much as you try to deceive others. Hasn’t your conscience bothered you even in the dark? I wish I could penetrate your soul as easily as I’ve penetrated your house, that house of mirrors and object d’art, but I suppose I’d find nothing but betrayal there: Nabawiyya disguised as Rauf, Rauf disguised as Nabawiyya, or Ilish Sidra in place of both—and betrayal would cry out to me that it was the lowest crime on earth. Their eyes behind my back must have traded anxious looks throbbing with lust, which carried them in a current crawling like death, like a cat creeping on ...

Paper 2 Outline: TATD + TFA

Prompt --> Pride can lead to failure and self-destruction or to accomplishment and self-fulfilment. Discuss the presentation of pride and its consequences in at least two of the works you have studied.  Thesis statement: In the Thief and the Dogs, Naguib Mahfouz allegorically represents the marxist ideology through the protagonist, Said Mahran who’s hubris leads him to self-destruction. Similarly, in TFA, Chinua Achebe utilises the tragic hero archetype to represent the danger of being rigid and inflexible, in a dynamic world, which reveal Achebe’s assertion of the need for duality to successfully navigate an ever-changing world. Topic sentence 1: In both novels, the protagonist’s overwhelming pride leads them to inevitable destruction at their own hands, seen with Okonkwo’s fatalistic suicide, and Said got assassinated. Topic sentence 2: In TATD and TFA, their pride catalyses their conflict, as their moral values aren’t heavily influenced by opposition, such as the...

Themes in TEWWG

1. TEWWG explores the theme of love and independence through Janie's various relationships including her journey for self-awareness and discovery. Janie's first relationships are indicative for recognizing what she truly desires for herself and in Jody's death, she understands the possession she now has of herself. Tea Cake is able to offer Janie the equality similar to her ideology of the perfect union from the pear tree analogy, however, this relationship's other flaws introduce to her the need for her own independence. Within Tea Cake's death, Janie is able to recognize the values from this relationship in their equality and her own self-awareness, enabling her to continue on this journey whilst the memories of Tea Cake continue to push her. The revelation she comes across is the possibility for independence and love to coexist which was thought originally unplausible. 2. Although racism is not of the biggest significance of this novel, Hurston does incorporate...